Cashback Offer from 15th to 20th April 2021. Get Flat 20% Cashback credited to your account for a minimum transaction of $80. Post Your Question Today!

Question DetailsNormal
$ 12.00

Choose 1 (one) of the following pair of competing claims

Question posted by
Online Tutor Profile
request

Choose 1 (one) of the following pair of competing claims. Carefully reconstruct and critically evaluate the most important arguments the relevant philosophers use to support their claims and/or critique that of the other. Who gets the better of the dispute, and why?
When reconstructing, make sure: to focus only on the one specific claim indicated; to use your own words as much as possible; to clarify any technical, controversial, or ambiguous terms; to explicate the precise meaning of the claim if necessary; to clearly state each of the premises or reasons used by the author; to explain the support for each of the premises or reasons; and to explain any missing premises or reasons, and their support, that you have supplied.

The point of a critical evaluation is to reach an overall assessment of the cogency of an argument. Metaphorically, one can think of the process as poking and prodding both the premises and the reasoning supporting the conclusion with potential problems or objections, in order to see whether the argument will stand up to reasoned scrutiny. Make sure attend to the validity or strength of the reasoning, the clarity of the terms and concepts, and the truth of the premises. It is also important to consider plausible or potential objections to your own evaluation and show exactly how such concerns may be answered.
The essay should be no longer than 1500 words. Put a word count on your paper. Indicate the numbers of the claim the paper treats. The essays must not be handwritten. The assignment is Tuesday December 16, by 1:00 p.m., in my office, Wheatley 05-007.

1.Hardin claims that there is a “ratchet effect” (862) between population growth and food aid that creates an inherently “pejoristic” (863) system. Pojman claims that the relationship between food aid and population growth is not inherently pejoristic.

2.Singer claims that “if it is in our power to prevent something bad from happening, without thereby sacrificing anything of comparable moral importance, we ought, morally, to do it” (889). Pojman claims that this principle is problematic, even when it is put forward in a weaker, qualified form.

3.Hardin claims that we should think of “the problem of the survival of the human species” (855) in terms of “the ethics of a lifeboat” (857). Murdoch & Oaten claim that Hardin’s lifeboat metaphor is “worthless—indeed detrimental—in discussions of food-population questions” (876).
 
4.Pojman claims that his “[m]oderate moral theory recognizes special responsibilities to family, friends, and neighbors” (910). Singer claims that “we cannot discriminate against someone merely because he is far away from us (or we are far way from him)” (889).
 

Available Answer
$ 12.00

[Solved] Choose 1 (one) of the following pair of competing claims

  • This Solution has been Purchased 1 time
  • Submitted On 24 Dec, 2014 11:42:57
Answer posted by
Online Tutor Profile
solution

Hardin argues that there is a felt ratchet effect between the population growth and food aid which is inherent in producing pejoristic system. Contrary, Pojman argues that the relationship between food aid and population growth have some close relationship. The two theorists pose contrasting arguments that calls for serious surveys as scholars. From Hardin’s ...

Buy now to view the complete solution
Other Similar Questions
User Profile
mtish...

choose 1 question from these 3

THE HOUSTON ASTROS "SIGN-STEALING" SCANDAL Name Course Date What Happened The Houston Astros sign stealing scandal is a historical contravention of ethics in which Houston Astros were engaged in a ...
User Profile
termp...

What Makes ______ the Best Place to Work and Why

Choose 1 company that you believe would be an ideal company to work for based on working conditions, salary, opportunity for advancement and work involved....
User Profile
termp...

Choose 1 U.S. environmental law. St

Choose 1 U.S. environmental law. State the name of the law and the date the law was passed.Summarize the major provisions of the law that you chose Clean Air Act...
User Profile
Homew...

Choose 1 (one) of the following pair of competing claims

Hardin argues that there is a felt ratchet effect between the population growth and food aid which is inherent in producing pejoristic system. Contrary, Pojman argues that the relationship between food aid and population g...

The benefits of buying study notes from CourseMerit

homeworkhelptime
Assurance Of Timely Delivery
We value your patience, and to ensure you always receive your homework help within the promised time, our dedicated team of tutors begins their work as soon as the request arrives.
tutoring
Best Price In The Market
All the services that are available on our page cost only a nominal amount of money. In fact, the prices are lower than the industry standards. You can always expect value for money from us.
tutorsupport
Uninterrupted 24/7 Support
Our customer support wing remains online 24x7 to provide you seamless assistance. Also, when you post a query or a request here, you can expect an immediate response from our side.
closebutton

$ 629.35